• Contact Us
  • Company (current)
    About Us Contact Us India Predictive Analytics
  •     Careers
  • Practice Areas
    Antitrust Damages Employment Energy Health Care Intellectual Property International Arbitration Data Analytics Valuation Finance & Securities
    Antitrust Damages Employment Energy Health Care Intellectual Property International Arbitration Data Analytics Valuation Finance & Securities
    EconOne Antitrust
    Antitrust
    EconOne Damages
    Damages
    EconOne Employment
    Employment
    EconOne Energy
    Energy
    EconOne Health Care
    Health Care
    EconOne Intellectual Property
    Intellectual Property
    EconOne International Arbitration
    International Arbitration
    EconOne Data Analytics
    Data Analytics
    EconOne Valuation
    Valuation
    EconOne Finance Securities
    Finance & Securities
    Services
    • Class Certification
    • Damages Analysis/Calculation
    • Liability Issues
    • Price Fixing
    • Regulation
    • Market Definition
    • Vertical/Horizontal Arrangements
    • Predatory Conduct
    • Price Discrimination
    • Unfair Competition
    • Market Power
    • Bundling/Tying
    • Exclusive Contracts
    • Consulting/Market Studies
    View Antitrust
    Services
    • Antitrust
    • Consumer Fraud
    • Contract Breach
    • Employment Issues
    • Intellectual Property
    • Oil & Gas/Royalty Disputes
    • Wrongful Termination/Death
    View Damages
    Services
    • Class Certification
    • Damages Analysis
    • Wage & Hour
    • Discrimination--Racial, Gender, Age
    • EEOC/OFCCP Compliance
    • Hiring, Termination, Promotion Analyses
    • Impact of Reduction in Force Actions
    • Racial Profiling
    • Personal Injury/Wrongful Death
    View Employment
    Services
    • Antitrust & Market Power
    • Contract Breach
    • International Arbitrations
    • Merger Analysis
    • Royalty Disputes
    • Project Finance
    • Asset Valuation
    • Renewable Energy
    • Bankruptcy Advisory
    View Energy
    Services
    • Antitrust
    • Breach of Contract
    • Damages Analysis
    • False Claim Act
    • Government Investigations
    • Qui Tam Litigation
    • Generic Delay
    • Paragraph IV Litigation
    • Hatch-Waxman Act Litigation
    • Commercial Payor
    • Reimbursement Disputes
    • Statistical Sampling
    View Health Care
    Services
    • Damages Analysis/Calculation
    • Lost Profits
    • Reasonable Royalty
    • Antitrust Counterclaims
    • Trade Secrets/Trade Dress
    • Copyright Infringement
    View Intellectual Property
    Services
    • Commercial Arbitration
    • Investment Treaty Arbitration
    • Mediations
    • Economic Damages Calculation
    • Socio-Economic & Environmental Damages Calculation
    • Financial Damages Calculation
    • Business Valuation
    • Forensic Accounting Investigations
    • Economic Analysis
    • Financial Analysis
    • Quantum Analysis
    • Competition Analysis
    • Regulatory Analysis
    • Causation Analysis
    • Statistical Analysis
    • Contract Disputes
    • Market Assessment
    • Prices Analysis
    • Energy Issues
    • Forensic Accounting Investigations
    • Natural Resources
    • Business Interruption Activities & Loss of Profits
    • Fraud & Money Laundering Investigations
    • Insurance Claims Litigation/Mediation
    View International Arbitration
    Services
    • Antitrust
    • Corporate Data Analyses & Forecasting
    • Predictive Modeling
    • Civil Rights
    • Employment Issues
    • Energy
    • Fraud
    • Regional Analysis
    View Data Analytics
    Services
    • Employment stock option valuation
    • Intellectual Property
    • Settlement Services
    • Business Valuation
    • Patents/Reasonable Royalty
    • Competitive Alternatives
    • Franchise Economics And Valuation
    View Valuation
    Services
    • Misstatement and Omissions
    • Event Study Analyses
    • Market Manipulation Claims
    • ERISA Claims
    • Insider Trading Allegations
    • Financial Portfolio Enhancement
    • Security & Portfolio Analysis
    • Trading & Marketing Dynamics
    • Strategy Testing
    View Finance & Securities
  • Resources
    News / Events Podcasts Inside Economics EconOne Box Login
  • Find an Expert

Houston Jury Awards Emergency Room Doctors $19.1 Million in Out-of-Network Reimbursement Dispute

Posted by Leslie Schafer
July 16, 2021

On June 24, 2021, a jury in Harris County, TX awarded two emergency care physician groups $19.1 million in damages for underpayment of healthcare claims by insurer Molina Healthcare of Texas, Inc. I was a testifying expert on behalf of the plaintiffs: ACS Primary Care Physicians Southwest, PA & Emergency Services of Texas, PA v. Molina Healthcare, Inc. and Molina Healthcare of Texas, Inc., No. 2017-77084, (Harris County, Texas, 113th Judicial District). ACS and EST sued Molina for underpaying more than 13,000 out-of-network claims for reimbursement between 2016 and 2019.

ACS & EST v. Molina was the first trial in the nation to assess the usual and customary rate of reimbursement for out-of-network emergency services covered by Affordable Care Act (“ACA”) health plans. Unlike other physicians, emergency room physicians are required by law to treat any patient who enters the emergency department. The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act of 1986 (“EMTALA”) mandates that hospital emergency departments screen, stabilize or transfer every patient who seeks emergency care, regardless of insurance status or ability to pay. Therefore, the Texas Insurance Code requires insurance companies to reimburse emergency services at either a contracted rate or a usual and customary rate if the services were provided out-of-network.

Molina argued that the usual and customary rate for ACA plans is the rate at which Medicare reimburses providers. ACS and EST argued that ACA health plans are commercial, not government and that claims should be reimbursed at billed charges or the commercial market rate. On an aggregate basis, similar out-of-network insurers paid about $1,042 per claim for which Molina paid only about $151. The jury found that Molina knowingly engaged in unfair or deceptive practices when underpaying ACS and EST.

COVID provided unique trial experiences. First, in order to accommodate social distancing, jury selection took place at NRG Energy Stadium in Houston (home to rodeo and the Houston Texans football team). Then, although the other witnesses and I testified in person in the courtroom, the judge allowed the public to watch all of the testimony through Zoom to support COVID restrictions.

Read more at: AZA Law and LAW360.

Share this article:


Leslie Schafer pic
Leslie Schafer
is a Managing Director with Econ One Research, Inc. She applies economic analysis and econometrics to liability and damages estimation for litigation matters concerning antitrust, intellectual property, false advertising, and health care reimbursement. Dr. Schafer has served as a testifying expert about the reasonable value for out-of-network health care services; differences between in-network and out-of-network […]
Read More about Leslie Schafer
Company
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • India
Resources
  • News / Events
  • Podcasts
Practice Areas
  • Antitrust
  • Damages
  • Employment
  • Energy
  • Health Care
  • Intellectual Property
  • International Arbitration
  • Data Analytics
  • Valuation
  • Finance & Securities
Location
  • Chennai
  • Denver
  • Houston
  • Los Angeles
  • Memphis
  • New Delhi
  • New York, NY
  • Sacramento
  • Washington, D.C.
  • Careers
  • Sitemap
  • Social Media

EconOne © 2023

  • Español